Ten Reasons Brilliant Compensation Is Not Brilliant Any More — Updated

Revised 28 August, 2008

1. Brilliant Compensation is an honest representation of the idea of building pyramid of workers with you at the top.

2. The idea is that you can, by some method of recruiting, create an army of workers UNDER you. The problem is that not every one can and that the resulting downlines require constant work to keep alive the notion that they can actually make a living in whatever the business is.

3. Every business I was ever in that modeled itself on Brilliant Compensation had people upline from me selling leads.

4. Upliners selling leads is a sleazoid business tactic and should be a red flag to anyone who is offered leads by their upline — or by the “opportunity” itself, for that matter.

5. Most Brilliant Compensation businesses (most MLMs that are operating online) require you to buy something even if they say they do not. Most require that you purchase either a) more product than you need or b) products for which you have little personal use or c) education that you can most likely get for free online with a bit of initiative.

What is Brilliant Compensation? Presumably the income you get for promoting the business to your downline. You are paid according to one of a number of compensation plans. The most seductive and the least likely to bear fruit over time are those which pay you when you add someone to your group. Often compensations plan change. I have known serious MLM workers who were essentially ruined when the plan changed.

6. Most compensation plans reward experienced networkers who have the skills needed and the time will to give full time and more to their enterprise. It goes without saying that this group is tiny in comparison to those who are brought in and led to believe promises of similar success. “You have to spend money to make money.”

How much do you have to spend on leads and other business necessities before the truth kicks in?

You are, at best, going to earn vastly less than you thought when you read promises of a full time income. At worst, you are going to say Sayonara to some of your expendable income or the savings you wagered on the hype you were given.

7. Brilliant Compensation was made to order for an Internet Audience several years ago. It is now entirely out of date.

Most showings of this famous Harvard-evoking “movie” seek to support the notion that you can build a home business, complete with an army of willing workers you recruit. Or, lately. workers placed under you for a price.

Enter the famed triad — leads, email ads, autoresponders.

Wow. All that. Hello?

Email marketing, even for the people who know how to do it, is not a winning venture. Some will argue to the contrary, but people who are well out of it admit to their losses honestly.

8. Brilliant Compensation is for more than 90 percent a pipe dream.

It assumes, like Frank Lloyd Wright, that people are very different than they actually are. Wright envisioned suburbs, believing everyone would have a little farm and plant their own garden. He drew the first interchanges of our strangling highway culture. We now have disfunctional metro sprawl filled with couch potatoes, broken marriages, bored children and vehicular traffic that helps poison the air we breathe.

Online we have a legion of confused souls who know, by now, that everything they are likely to touch in the way of an opportunity will turn to stone.

9. The only truly Brilliant Compensation is an inherently sound system for generating income.

One such system is product-based capitalism.

Another is product-based advertising, the very source of most of the revenue made by our communications industries and media.

Many of us who cut our teeth on MLMs and similar programs in the late 1990s ended up in a few programs built on cash-cycling premises. The pejorative word for such programs was and remains Ponzi schemes. The advent of Bernard Madoff has made Ponzi anathema as a concept. The simplest answer I can give to those who wonder if there is a prayer that such money cycling schemes can work is no. At one point I felt differently. I believed that if an enterprise could raise capital from a broad constituency and use it to create even more wealth, there was hope of attaining results that defied normal notions of a return on investment.

My experience was that there were systemic, technological and human reasons for the failure of these efforts. Rather on the same principle that calories in require more calories out to result in weight reduction, a money in money out system that promises an outlandish return is bound to falter over time. The technology needed to actually deal with the numbers that would flood to such an opportunity is well beyond the capacity of persons who might create it. Once this became obvious the best will in the world could not prevent the business from failing. At every point in this situation human limitations kick in.

In one case I remained in such business I felt it was unable to maintain its commitments. At that point I resigned and made my resignation public. In another case I and everyone else took losses when the business simply came to an end. The lesson was learned.

Far be it from me to suggest an online alternative to Brilliant Compensation.

10. I could go on and on, but I want to end with phone culture. Nothing is more demeaning to me than the idea of calling someone on the phone and reading a script. I have dehumanized myelf by this route to Brilliant Compensation.

It is probably the most bothersome aspect of the whole MLM ritual. I am happy to be out of it.

One final note. The U.S. Social Security system is Ponzi-like because money in is used to pay people now and there is no guarantee that it will be there to pay those who put it in today for some far off future. But there remains no substitute for the development of what can be called real rather than brilliant compensation. That would be compensation for services rendered (or goods created and sold) that creates profit and some willingness of those who succeed to aid those whose returns are, for whatever reason, inadequate to maintain themselves.


4 thoughts on “Ten Reasons Brilliant Compensation Is Not Brilliant Any More — Updated

  1. Derrick says:

    Wow, this article really confirms that you cannot believe at least half of the stuff you read on the internet. The only people who will read this article and walk away thinking it makes sense are people cut from the same cloth…people who simply think they can get something for nothing. Brilliant Compensation explains perfectly how network marketing works. The one key ingredient though is YOU have to WORK. If you WORK and follow sound already proven format, and are not looking for excuses, you will SUCCEED. Period. I hope the author of this article has a day job.

  2. Stephen C. Rose says:

    I have heard it all before. I have no quarrel with hard work. I am 76 and work 12 hours a day with little compensation but a great deal of joy and pleasure. I do not like the world of that sort of promotion and selling. I enjoyed my time in it but was not cut out for it. I am a poet, musician, writer and so forth who happens to believe that cyberspace is the future and that there are many ways to monetize. I pursue some of them as we speak. Selling products with my original artwork and publishing Kindle books. Each one to her own taste. Cheers.

  3. Anonymous says:

    that is a long winded explanation of how you cannot be bothered to get off your backside and learn the skills necessary to do well a something, get a life instead of writing blogs on how bad things are

  4. you didn’t argue against any of the points made in “Brilliant Compensation” because you know that you cannot. Fact is the logic is sound, you just seem sad because you got burned in the past. Duh the system requires work, but the soundness and legitimacy is represented by the fact that almost every single major corporation has some form of network distribution built into their organization. Coca Cola is a good example. Simply put, you either don’t understand the concept, you didn’t even watch “Brilliant Compensation” or you didn’t receive the training required or take it upon yourself to train yourself to be the kinda of person it takes to succeed. 1% of people succeed because the remaining 99% do nothing but make excuses or justify the excuses of others. Shame on you for trying to deter the honest souls who have a harder work ethic and more desire to live than you appear to have. The only important factor in network marketing is which company you choose to join. Of course it helps to join one with a humanitarian aim and a proven background just as when looking at any other job opportunity. Network marketing is an extremely viable and practical tool for creating leverage and promoting wealth when used in the right manner. Your argument is basically that the system has been abused. Yet so has capitalism (which by the way mlm is a part of), and so is socialism and every other for of ism. The majority of people choose to abuse the things they do not fully understand while the wise and patience reap the true rewards of appreciation and determination.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s