politics

My First and Last Sotomayor Post


This is a closed case that will be a summer cash cow for people who make money taking sides. She will be confirmed and that’s that.

The following observations are random and close the subject for me.

Jonathan Turley has projected an image of such snobbery toward the nominee that he ranks in my mind as the Paul Krugman of legal opinions. Both men are right half the time. (Interestingly. Turley modified his snarky initial reaction later for KO — guests on MSNBC do not merely reappear, they appear serially from show to show — intensifying viewer alienation.)

I refuse to watch MSNBC talk all summer about this.

I refuse to get upset when all the opponents of Obama can do conclude that all he cares about is his socialist agenda. Barack Obama is an Alinsky veteran who inclines to democracy and realizes the limitations of community organization. That is why he ran for President. He is for a mixed system that seeks to bring out the best in the both private and public sectors. He is above all smart, smarter than his opponents for the most part, and miles smarter than the people on his side who want to grouse rather than follow his lead.

He put out his A team yesterday to take on the media and, if you watched Jarret, Axelrod and Gibbs, you got a carefully-honed message that nonplussed the conflict-hungry MSM. It was a delight to see.

Following the President does not mean agreeing all the time. It means supporting when you can and cutting some slack when you cannot. And realizing that we are gently moving past the era of binary and double binds in respect to … us.

Republican opposition to Sotomayor will make their loss of standing among Hispanics a veritable sentence of doom upon their electoral hopes for at least the next two rounds. Even McCain seems to understand this, pushing back on Limbaugh-Rove.

Slurs of Santomajor have already begun online and no doubt elsewhere. Each of these will leave her in a more powerful position.

Democrats should probably pray for Republican opposition as it will only help a party which is itself reeling from its own internal contradictions. The jury is still out on about half of the Democrats in high office as far as I am concerned. Maybe the Sotomayor chapter will provide an occasion for Democratic unanimity and repentance for their shameful performance on the Gitmo Closing vote.

My final observation will please no Democrat. It is very simple and possibly even correct:

The Sotomayor who is being thinly excoriated by an asinine corps of Republican talking heads could well become the Souter of the Democrats. Her record is mixed enough and has enough blanks on issues that the High Court considers that we cannot tell if she is a lock on all the reflexive expectations of doctrinaire Democrats. As with President Obama, we may find that, with Sotomayor, empathy runs both ways. And that winking and nodding does not work with prospective lifetime high court judges with minds of their own.

Standard

3 thoughts on “My First and Last Sotomayor Post

  1. What those previous posters said, LOL. Except for the Maddow bashing; if you don’t like it, don’t watch. I despise Limbaugh, so I don’t watch. Simple enough. I’m glad to see a female amongst all the male pundits.

  2. Phil says:

    Well put Stephen – exactly what I would have said had I written it – only not as good as you just did. The case is closed. Thank you for pointing out Turley and his issues. He cheapens Olbermann’s and Rachel’s shows. Rachel doesn’t need anymore cheapening.

  3. CL Reimer says:

    Excellent observations. I’ll be following and watching for the Souter-Sotomayor correlation and praying it never becomes a reality.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s